« John Seely Brown: The Online Social Life of Narratives | Main | China & Virtual Property »

Apr 27, 2004

TrackBack

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.typepad.com/services/trackback/6a00d8341c022953ef00d83420cc7a53ef

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference Reading Everquest:

» Links from Jason Craft
What I'm reading. No time for comments: I'm trying to get a review copy to the committee by the end of the month. A Theory of Literary Production by Pierre Macherey Dylan Horrocks' new essay (via slashdot) Hayot and Wesp's... [Read More]

» DaVinci Heats Up Travel Industry and Virgin Vacations Has Just the Fling from Virgin Vacations
Trackback URI: http://www.prweb.com/zingpr.php/Q3Jhcy1NYWduLVByb2YtUHJvZi1IYWxmLVplcm8= [Read More]

» Johnson: Piston's Becoming Prisoners of 3-Pointers from 24 percent of
24 percent of those. This season, it has been a different story for the Pistons, and it looks as if they tore a page from the Spurs' [Read More]

» North Korea's Message to Syria from of greetings
of Syria, on the occasion of the 43rd anniversary of the March 8 revolution in Syria. In the message [Read More]

» Handset Theft Amongst Adolescents Reaches New Heights from and other forms
theft and other forms of mobile phone crime in the UK has become a widespread [Read More]

» Broad Immune Response In Mice Unduced By Radiation-killed Bacteria Vaccine from by gamma irradiation,
the National Institute of Allergy and Infectious Diseases (NIAID), part of the National [Read More]

Comments

1.

Hayot and Wesp mention how politically imbued readings of VWs/games might become.

How much transfer can there be between in-game and out-of-game political value systems? Beyond even role-classification (do more Democrats play clerics?!), I would be sceptical of how well basic game-play behavior/ motiviations etc. correlate with external political behavior.

2.

Hey, Nathan,

I'm pretty sure (though I can't speak for Ted) that by political we didn't mean "Democrat or Republican," but something slightly more unconscious (that might manifest itself eventually, to be sure, in a voting booth choice).

That is, if EQ convinces people that, for instance, "success is a matter of hard work" (which seems likely to be one of the consequences of a system in which all avatars are created equal), they would be likely to resent twinks who achieve the material trappings of success without the labor. At the same time, they might also resent what I'll call "whiners," people who complain that life is hard, that things are unfair, and then beg for handouts from higher-level players.

Does that translate into RL politics? Hard to say. But: GWB is a twink; people on welfare are "whiners" (not what I think, but how the analogy works). Depending on your relation to EQ, and the manner in which it implements or doesn't implement rules that you believe should regulate these kinds of behaviors (twinking, begging), it seems likely that you'll have a much more intense relationship to that set of rules than you do to the RL political versions (the inheritance tax, Aid to Families with Dependent Children).

And then, given that your relation to the EQ versions is more intense (and therefore more unconscious), I could imagine a situation in which EQ effectively "teaches" you a RL political stance.

That said, in the preceeding stuff I've just been acting as though "political" was only a RL category. But as the various articles published by Terra Nova writers have shown, categories like "person," "property," or "economy" operate in online RPGs--even when the people involved don't know that those categories operate. "Politics" seems to me to be a similar kind of category.

3.

Nate,

I agree with all Eric said. You might also be interested in Beth Kolko's "Bodies in Place: Real Politics, Real Pedagogy, and Virtual Space."
You can find it in High Wired: On the Design, Use, and Theory of Educational MOOs.

Kolko builds on work by Amy Bruckman and Donna Harraway to point out how creating virtual identity and operating within virtual societies must entail political considerations. Actually, the Kolko article is a lot closer to another paper that Eric and Ted presented at the Princeton conference. I'll probably post something about that one before too long.

4.

现在的青少年由于饮食、遗传等原因生理上成熟早,同时身处在这个浮躁的社会,那些被人们盲目追捧的轻浮的流行时尚,到处可见的成人用品,很容易让人们尤其是青少年产生性冲动,了解一些性知识是有益而无害的。
wow gold world of warcraft gold发表

The comments to this entry are closed.